THE FUNCTIONS OF FICTION | Chapter One

I don’t know how Oscar said goodbye to Lucinda – did he say it at all? I didn’t read all of Oscar And Lucinda, you see. I began reading the Peter Carey book, believing it to be a lovely love story about two gamblers, the tale of how the narrator’s grandfather, Oscar, ended up with the narrator’s grandmother, Lucinda. I was wrong.

I am more Apollonian than Dionysian. I like order, harmony and happy endings. I can, and do, live with unhappy endings in movies. Most movies end before I can invest in them emotionally, after all. Books demand more of my time. When I like a book, when I like its protagonists, I want happy endings for them and a big positive payoff for me. So I fast-forward books to find out. I read one chapter here, another chapter there, then I go to the ending: Is it happy, is it unhappy and if it is unhappy, how unhappy do things get? For example, I knew Anna Karenina wouldn’t live happily ever after – it meant nothing to me for I didn’t like her – but I had to know if her in-laws, Kitty and Levin, would. (They would.) For example, What I Loved was sad but bearably so. After I read the ending, I could rewind the book and read the rest. Maybe the title, in past tense, had prepared me for the ending. Maybe I had learnt to be less cowardly, more grown-up. Maybe I had learnt not to box books – nor life – up.

But back when I was younger and reading Oscar And Lucinda, I couldn’t continue past the part when Mrs What’s-her-name, that tricky terrible widow, somehow seduced Oscar. She as good as raped him, really, then she got pregnant with his child, then she got him tied to her for life. Untied from Lucinda. I hated her, that Mrs What’s-her-name. How could she? How could Oscar? I was cross with Carey, too. I wanted to tell him, “It’s Oscar And Lucinda, not Oscar And That Woman. I want Lucinda to be the grandma. I don’t want that woman to be the grandma.”

The book went back to the library. That was the end of that, I thought. How was I to know the book would come back to bite me? I didn’t know the Oscar in my life would turn out to be an Oscar. I didn’t know I would turn out to be an Oscar-less Lucinda. I never saw that chapter with Mrs What’s-her-name coming. It came, oh it came. There was a child, their child, and there may be a grandchild, their grandchild, one day, not that I am hoping to hear from them.

How did Lucinda take it? What did she say? What did she do? Who ended it with whom? I don’t know. Never read the rest. But the tale of my Oscar and I came to the bitter end one morning, after months of mutual misery. He called me. One of the first – one of the last things he said to me, with a very final finality, was, “This is goodbye.”

And I have lived with it.